Mystery Supply Co.

Celebrating nostalgic pop culture that is spooky and kooky!

Vintage horror, sci-fi, and comic book themed prints, apparel, and gifts.

Mystery Supply Co. Laughing Skull



High quality prints, t-shirts, and more. I started out selling digitally restored vintage movie posters here in 2021, and soon after added mugs, blankets, tapestries, t-shirts, pint glasses, and canvases.


Not on Etsy? No problem. The main online store has just about¬† everything the Etsy store has! I rarely offer discounts on Etsy, but if you’re on the newsletter, I offer exclusive discounts in our own shop! Sign up for the newsletter below!

Creature From the Black Lagoon


I spend a lot of time working on the YouTube channel. I started out uploading Etsy product videos, then moved into making Scooby-Doo ambiance videos.

I have plans for other types of content as I find time!

Check it out!

Shop Until You Drop. . . Dead!

Through the passage behind the rotating bookcase lies the shop..where you’ll find our latest prints, gifts, and apparel. “Put…the candle…BACK!”

Elvira Mistress of the Dark Print - Mystery Supply Co.

Elvira Mistress of the Dark Print

Creature From the Black Lagoon Pillow - Mystery Supply Co.

Creature From the Black Lagoon Double Sided Pillow

Wicked Witch of the West T-Shirt - Mystery Supply Co.

Wicked Witch of the West T-Shirt

Join Us . . . The Children of the Night!

Whispers From The Crypt

Blog posts on vintage horror, science fiction, pulps, comics, pin-ups and numerous other oddities from the fringes of pop culture!